On Thursday, Sept. 6, 2007, a nude picture of Vanessa Hudgens, Disney Channel’s “High School Musical” star, surfaced on multiple websites. This caused turmoil because she was only 18-years-old and a role model on a family friendly television channel.
The same day, her rep issued a statement saying that the photograph “was taken privately. It is a personal matter and it is unfortunate that this has become public.” The photo was meant to be seen only by her boyfriend and co-star Zac Efron, but was somehow leaked on the Internet.
Hudgens learned that the photos would break in the media from her manager and a few days later while she was vacationing in Australia, the pictures surfaced.Friday, Hudgens released a formal statement through her rep that said, “I want to apologize to my fans, whose support and trust means the world to me. I am embarrassed over this situation and regret having ever taken these photos.”
Rumors that her contract with Disney was in danger began to spread. People were worried that because she was a respected figure on a kid’s television network, this might affect her career. However, rumors quickly ended when a Disney Channel spokesperson released this statement: “Vanessa has apologized for what was obviously a lapse in judgment. We hope she’s learned a valuable lesson.”
After the scandal and her formal apology statement, Hudgens talked about the lesson she had learned in an interview with Seventeen magazine. She said “with the Internet these days, you don’t have a personal life. Nothing is private: Everyone knows everything, and they can find out everything about you. You’re not as safe as you think you are, and you have to be aware of the people you’re around.” And about the uproar that the pictures caused, Hudgens stated “It was very traumatic, and I am extremely upset it happened. I hope all my fans can learn from my mistake and make smart decisions. But I wouldn’t have been able to get through it if it wasn’t for my family, friends and fans, who supported me all along the way.”
In all of the mainstream media, the stories portray Hudgens as innocent, emphasizing her apology statements to the public. The stories avoid going into details of why she took the photos for her boyfriend and how this inappropriate behavior contradicts with her wholesome image on the Disney Channel. Instead the media focus on her remorse. For example, one headline featured in People magazine reads, “Vanessa Hudgens ‘Embarrassed,’ Apologizes for Nude Photo,” and was accompanied by a beautiful picture of her with a charming smile. In the mainstream articles, Hudgens is quoted most often. She speaks on behalf of herself through formal apology statements issued directly to the public, through her rep, or through interviews. There are no foes of the celebrity quoted, or anyone else speaking negatively about her. In conclusion, the mainstream media downplayed the incident, portraying Hudgens as a young, innocent girl who made a forgivable mistake.
The blog sites portray Hudgens in a slightly unfavorable light. None of the blog sites express a very strong opinion about the incident, but instead have a rather satirical, mocking tone. On one blog site, the headline reads,“Hudgens: To Go ‘Wild’?” and jokes about Hudgens striking a deal on “Girls Gone Wild” if Disney were to drop her. The picture accompanying the headline is a seductive photo of her blowing a kiss with the words “Breaking News” in red above it, creating a provocative tone. Other blog sites ignore the ramifications of her actions and instead joke about her presence of pubic hair in the picture. In conclusion, the blog sites don’t see this scandal as having much importance to their audience, but find it amusing that the wholesome image of Disney posed nude. The blog sites don’t attempt to damage Hudgens image, but portray her as a young, promiscuous teenager hiding under a “good girl” cover.
The difference between coverage in mainstream media and blogs is that they are speaking to different audiences, so their portrayal of Hudgens is somewhat contrasting. For example, mainstream media is speaking to a wider audience, including parents of children who watch the Disney Channel and are fans of Hudgens. This audience is more concerned with the celebrity’s apology and downplay of the incident. In contrast, blog sites are mostly visited by college-middle aged adults who find the foolish mistakes of celebrities entertaining, and have no concern with her image on the Disney Channel.
Under her circumstances as a role model to young children, I think that Hudgens handled the crisis very well. She apologized directly to the public and fans, acknowledged that she made a mistake, and went on to say that she had learned a valuable lesson from this incident. In this situation, as her publicist I would have had her handle the situation the same way.